To begin with, I believe in ethical, moral objectivity. I
believe there's no particular problem in proving this/make a good case for
it.
1. That the ethical system is flawless in the sense that there is no
obvious allowance of moral wrongdoing in it.
2. "...ethical claims are
objective if it is possible for agents who make them to do so correctly or
incorrectly. Objectivity in this sense implies the possibility of moral
error.(3)" That is to say that moral mistakes exist, not that moral errors are
committed ethically.
3. "...ethical claims are objective if they are
'answerable to substantial [ethical] facts and properties in the world that
exist independently of the contingent practice of making those claims and the
relevant attitudes of those who make them' (p. 6)(1).(4)"
4. "...ethical
claims are objective if reasonable agents competent with the concepts that
constitute them would converge in 'favorable circumstances of rational inquiry'
(p. 7)(2).(5)" That is to say, in my opinion, that there are objective moral
duties in relation to the object in question.
From the book review of
(1)(2)Hallvard Lillehammer's Companions in Guilt: Arguments for Ethical
Objectivity written by (3)(4)(5)Terence Cuneo in the journal Mind Volume 118,
Number 470, April 2009, ISSN 0026-4423.
It's also worth mentioning the
book of Paul Bloomfield's Moral Reality, OUP, 2004 that the review
mentions.
I see the description of an Ethical Objective system as an
(mathematical) intersection of the above 4 points. The Ethical Objective system
should thus satisfy the most strict and strongest requirements for such a
system. It's worth noting that it should be humanly possible to fit into it with
a least one member, one human being, and that it should live up to general
requirements of plausibility and reasonability.
One more thing: I think
it should be noted that "reasonable agents" mean people who are able to separate
right from wrong and are basically in agreement with the actual system of ethics
in question. If the case is otherwise, they fall into a different group and are
not relevant to the system that is being discussed. This may limit the number of
people who can adhere to that system quite severely, but that is the nature of
the current diversity of humanity.
I've made some additions to the book
review and as such the whole is more a new argument than a factual instance that
I like to address.
The framework for every Ethical Objective System can
be as extensive as every legal framework as I see it, without imposing
particular problems.
The further work to the Ethical Objectivity is this.
The obstacle one meets is concerning depth. I think the human cognition decides
the depth of the ethical system's reach, absolutely and objectively, of the
Ethical Objectivity discussed. If the human being can't have knowledge about a
deeper fact of nature then one can't also say that the human being can commit
any mistakes in that relation. It's therefore of no use to point to a phenomenon
that lies outside the normal or possible human cognition because a sufficient
ethically objective system isn't constructed at all to take care of those
phenomena's ethical content. No matter what, the ethically objective system will
therefore relate to our common life-world, the life-world that one can actually
say something objective about. It's therefore the case that all hypothetical
micro- and macro-phenomena are outside the domain that actually can have some
influence on the human being's ethical and moral life. It's therefore not
decisive to have absolute knowledge to have an efficient ethical objective
system as long as one does one's duties for the best in this actual effective
ethical objective system in what concerns information and possibilities. In that
kind of view, one can plausibly say that doctors in ancient history may have
been acting ethically objective in some cases, if not all, of course, despite a
very limited knowledge about the human body. It's clear that science will form
an outer frame for our life-worlds wherein this Ethical Objective System
functions as in the question of preventive measures concerning Global Climate
Changes and also about our limitations in size of total world population that
should or can exist without collapsing into chaos and extinction of being
examples of conscious beings capable of knowledge, possibly effecting one's own
salvation.
Consequently, let's look at abortion again. What if two
parties agree on the fact that guilt may not apply for abortion because there
are factors that speak strongly for and against as well as the indeterminate
status of the fetus to be removed, both on brain function and emotional
function(1) when the procedure is carried out? Thus, abortion for these two
parties remains a private, informed and "esoteric" decision, yet respected by
either party in companionship without guilt!
Hypothetically speaking,
it's plausible to say that being a human without an ethical system in the 21st
century and aligning oneself with the ancient humans and humanoids like the
Cro-Magnons, seems just crazy! It's laying such a waste to a whole heritage,
legacy of philosophical civility! The ancient humans before civilization can be
said to be driven by evolutionary, biological instincts! Nihilism, relativism or
other destructive ethical approaches are historically insensitive, possibly
rationally insensitive, absurd or out of touch.
As much as Paul
Bloomfield makes the argument of having and maintaining good physical health,
I'd like to add the following:
It should be possible to determine Integrity,
Mental Health and Physical Health by keeping one's ethics. People may fool
themselves, but I think that the most sensitive factor of these three, being
Integrity, is very much affected by both bad attitude/mindset and bad actions,
altogether being bad morals and possibly bad ethics.
Through the arsenal
of diagnostics like various lie-detectors, (f)MRI-scans, interviews, somatic
examinations and what have you it should be possible to make good judgment on
the status of these 3 factors, Integrity, Mental Health and Physical Health. Any
reasonable doubt can therefore be removed for what kind of companion one is
socialising with. Any person with substantial deviation in either Integrity,
Mental Health and Physical Health from the characteristics that are condoned by
exactly this Ethical Objectivity can thus be excluded from the desirable group
of people that comply with Ethical Objectivity. The days of the Arguments of
Companions in Guilt are consequently numbered!
It should be a fundamental
belief that morality/ethics is to respect rationality in others, also the
potential of such in others, eg. children. This doesn't capture ecology very
well, but I can think of it as intelligent/rational to allow nature and animals
alike a natural life (for various reasons) incl. agricultural/aquacultural.
Thus, as this is a facet of being rational as a person, every person should
respect people with ecological views and the ecological view therefore becomes
the only ethical view in this respect, a general starting point.
Rationality
in this sense is nothing mysterious. It's just the capacity to score well/great
on IQ-tests, having a fine, intelligent flow of thoughts and doing a good or
great working performance, whatever this may be, being in the stream so to
speak!
Although I've written about rationality above I like to write the
following to make it perfectly clear. There are (at least) two kinds of
Rationality that it's fair to speak of. One is the rationality according to
function, being the way you apply your mind to whatever problems, practical or
intellectual. The other one is rationality as in being of good mental health,
being well-developed. It should be clear that rationality is the top premise of
this Ethically Objective system that I ascribe and develop from a Neo-Kantian
position.
This is a writing for removing any religious notion to the word
Rationality and thus the system of Rationality may seem reasonable to everyone.
I'm in doubt whether I. Kant has meant any religiousness at all with his
"kingdom of ideas". People have interpreted it this way, but I can't see that
there's a single factual instance of this in his text. Quite the opposite, I
think he thinks that the common person is able to make clever thoughts, to take
part in the "kingdom of ideas". I find this a much more charitable reading of
him and it makes him look better too!
Repugnance and appeal to
emotions/feelings/aestheticism are not any good way to get there even though I
support every argument that makes a good foundation for Ethical
Objectivity.
It should be noted that people of good moral attitude and
behaviour seem better able to create and maintain, by keeping the duties, social
relationships both in symmetric and asymmetric terms.
I'm with Dr. Sam
Harris when he argue by objectivity of flourishing and happiness, potentially by
and in everyone, on TED Talks that some/all moral questions or some/all outside
spectrums of some/all moral spectrums can be answered by science. Now, I don't
know if this is consensus within a group of scientists and philosophers alike
and if this is documented by scientific articles. He does mention psychology and
neuro-science as two (obvious) angles to answer this scientifically. It must be
admitted by myself, whether or not Dr. Sam Harris agrees, however, that
flourishing and happiness are still normative, unscientific, ethical objectives.
One can indeed be relatively poor and still be generally happy and one can work
too much and thus flourish beyond one's happiness. It's also a question to what
ends we are supposed to be flourishing and happy. Where does this flourishing
and happiness lead to if there's no destination in sight? Isn't then life only a
matter of taste and artistry in life? What about doing extreme sports and other
activities where one does risk one's own life? The question is not so much a
matter of this risk-taking person's life, but this person's social connections,
possibly causing grief in these people by the risk-taking. Thus, it's yet to see
to what extent one can fully argue that the objectives of flourishing and
happiness can be scientific. Indeed, this scientific notion has implicitly some
kind of normative destiny to it that Dr. Sam Harris is in debt to
answer.
It's admirable of Dr. Sam Harris of denoting this "scientific",
given the normative objectives, and at the same time quenching the lunatics who
promote death and destruction. It's certainly worth a thorough scientific study
of what underlying causes there are for people's misfortunes when it's so
commonly known that most or all people like to be happy, flourishing or
both.
(1)Remark concerning abortion by The Royal College of Obstetricians
and Gynaecologists (RCOG):
By The Royal College of Obstetricians and
Gynaecologists (RCOG),
"Fetal Awareness - Review of Research and
Recommendations for Practice".
From this
link:
http://www.rcog.org.uk/fetal-awareness-review-research-and-recommendations-practice
Fetal
Awareness
* The fetus cannot feel pain before 24 weeks because the
connections in the fetal brain are not fully formed
* Evidence examined by
the Working Party showed that the fetus, while in the chemical environment of
the womb, is in a state of induced sleep and is unconscious
* The Working
Party concluded that because the 24 week-old fetus has no awareness nor can it
feel pain, the use of analgesia is of no benefit
* More research is needed
into the short and long-term effects of the use of fetal analgesia post-24
weeks.
The full report:
http://www.rcog.org.uk/files/rcog-corp/RCOGFetalAwarenessWPR0610.pdf
Article,
this particular webpage, is published: 25/06/2010 (summary and
more).
Game over! You lose, relativists and subjectivists! I'd say there
is no objection by the subjectivists and relativists that can overcome Ethical
Objectivity (now)! I've been meditating this for quite a while and I'm now at
peace by the preceding sentences. There is simply no chance to refute Ethical
Objectivity anymore.
The argument is not finished by these words and
remains to be made a paper of academic quality, if not a book.
By Terje Lea / Leonardo F. Olsnes-Lea, 2009 - 2010, 2012 - and still ongoing.
By Terje
Lea, 11th November, 2009, 9th December, 2009, 11th December, 2009, 6th March,
2010, 24th March, 2010, 26th March, 2010, 12th April, 2010, 22nd April, 2010,
25th April, 2010, 26th April, 2010, 4th May, 2010, 10th May, 2010, 9th June,
2010, 28th June, 2010 and 24th October, 2010. Minor change of title,
18.11.2010. Now controlled under my new name, Leonardo F. Olsnes-Lea.
This blog holds philosophy issues only in order to make it easier for people who are only interested in philosophy to stay clear from all else that's not related.
Showing posts with label Ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ethics. Show all posts
Sunday, 30 September 2012
Friday, 21 September 2012
Over Animal Ethics and to PETA Too - This time it is the pigs...
Over PETA again and domestic animals, being a part of the animal ethics and applied ethics
This time it is over the pigs. The suggestion is one of multi-modal-approach, that the covers/shelters to wind and rain out on the grass fields must be in place, or at least is in place normatively as by recommendation and that one arranges for the animals to have special birth-bins with half-concrete (but enough still) and half-grass mat as with the cows and oxes formerly explained. Ordinary bins as with the cows and oxes (although they are called "stalls") should also be arranged for, but pigs are less complicated because they are not milked! Then the rest is up to you. Some even play music for the animals. This also concerns food and so on. Cleanliness level should be as high as vet standards demand and general animal standards outside this is also (largely/sufficiently) described by vet standards! Good luck to you, the farmers, the agronomists!
Note: For whatever the shelters, the bins, the stalls, animals do not walk about sharp edges very well and get easily cut up! This is also a notice, but probably already well into the vet's recommendations!
Note2: Just published to Facebook as message under profile and note also. Today, 2012-09-21 CEST.
This time it is over the pigs. The suggestion is one of multi-modal-approach, that the covers/shelters to wind and rain out on the grass fields must be in place, or at least is in place normatively as by recommendation and that one arranges for the animals to have special birth-bins with half-concrete (but enough still) and half-grass mat as with the cows and oxes formerly explained. Ordinary bins as with the cows and oxes (although they are called "stalls") should also be arranged for, but pigs are less complicated because they are not milked! Then the rest is up to you. Some even play music for the animals. This also concerns food and so on. Cleanliness level should be as high as vet standards demand and general animal standards outside this is also (largely/sufficiently) described by vet standards! Good luck to you, the farmers, the agronomists!
Note: For whatever the shelters, the bins, the stalls, animals do not walk about sharp edges very well and get easily cut up! This is also a notice, but probably already well into the vet's recommendations!
Note2: Just published to Facebook as message under profile and note also. Today, 2012-09-21 CEST.
Tuesday, 7 August 2012
Over the Scientism-Scientists and Mysticism-Scientists... - Applied Ethics +
Formal declaration of science: I hereby declare that Mysticism has deafeated the
Scientism, the Scientists! This is a final verdict for what I consider the
remaining time of humanity!Additionally, I predict that unless the obstructive
part to this understanding dies away, the consequences will be severe for the
entire Earth because of their, the Scientists, lack of sensitivity toward
Ethics! So, Zeta, (greek letter) all matters considered the Earth is in a
(strange) way HALTED in achieving progress in all fields, science broadly
interpreted!Not that Scientism by this is any more serious. No, the primary
matter here is how one considers Ethics to be a part of the Scientist's
education, discipline and attitude in conducting science and in being a leader
of science in society, i.e., how science plays out in the World by itself or in
the expression of technology!
BTW, this addresses in particular the psychologists and psychiatrists and what "that industry generates", given by the above and as last section under the Theorem, The Theorem for the Break against Nazi-Ideology or Not!
Over the Scientism-Scientists and (Respects-to-Mysteries/)Mysticism-Scientists, I have the following: The Scientism-Scientists can use all implants they want and commit all the moron monkey-biz sh*t, but they _will never_ achieve anything more than being mere academic (male/female) sl*ts, no matter what fraud they take part in! This is now more or less settled from my side. Let's see how they (try to) comply with the academic standards into the future!
Take care!
Note: That they see me as one of greatest worth, doesn't of course mean that I submit to their lunatic gambles (with everything worthwhile gambled FOR, all measures used, down to the hardest (medical) torture) because I've chosen side, I KNOW!!!
Note2: NOT in any can it be perceived that the "Mystics" in this weak sense, respecting the mysteries of Nature, stand lower than the Scientists in terms of science and scientific seriousness and productivity! This writing is simply not for the (religious) Mystics!!!
Note3: A note has been made on Facebook by this time-stamp, Tuesday, 7 August 2012 at 15:36 CEST, from another note concerning the Cyberpunk Corpus of all sorts writers.
BTW, this addresses in particular the psychologists and psychiatrists and what "that industry generates", given by the above and as last section under the Theorem, The Theorem for the Break against Nazi-Ideology or Not!
Over the Scientism-Scientists and (Respects-to-Mysteries/)Mysticism-Scientists, I have the following: The Scientism-Scientists can use all implants they want and commit all the moron monkey-biz sh*t, but they _will never_ achieve anything more than being mere academic (male/female) sl*ts, no matter what fraud they take part in! This is now more or less settled from my side. Let's see how they (try to) comply with the academic standards into the future!
Take care!
Note: That they see me as one of greatest worth, doesn't of course mean that I submit to their lunatic gambles (with everything worthwhile gambled FOR, all measures used, down to the hardest (medical) torture) because I've chosen side, I KNOW!!!
Note2: NOT in any can it be perceived that the "Mystics" in this weak sense, respecting the mysteries of Nature, stand lower than the Scientists in terms of science and scientific seriousness and productivity! This writing is simply not for the (religious) Mystics!!!
Note3: A note has been made on Facebook by this time-stamp, Tuesday, 7 August 2012 at 15:36 CEST, from another note concerning the Cyberpunk Corpus of all sorts writers.
Tuesday, 26 June 2012
The Implausible Slippery Slope Argument - Applied Ethics
The implausible slippery slope argument from the opposition is this,
- the "Slippery Slope" defeats itself (by fake ethics) by protecting hugely crazy people who have absolutely no problems accepting the devastation brought by it on human dignity and human worth/decency and how torture inflicts terror and deep fears, even sublimely, on the rest of the population.
- secondly, and more directly, the Slippery Slope never accounts for formal qualification, while citing this Nazi program "so seriously", "as if their whole bodies would be immersed", such as obtaining 3-year therapy after the age of 18 before getting the approval for suicide!
- "The Slippery Slope", in addition, has no concept or credible prediction for how many people Slippery Slope will affect outside those already, virtually, queued in! When 36 000 people die from guns (or gun deaths) in USA every year, would the rest of USA therefore get killed by guns next year? NO! Why is this? Because troubles need to obtain in certain ways first! This has a direct analogy to legislated suicides in that this counters the very Slippery Slope argument and the way these disgusting people (complex, as with traits of psychopathy and mis-a/-ophiles) remain active in society, "defending humanity" still! There is no doubt where I want: (Assisted) Suicides need legal defence/legislation and practice urgently so that people can achieve greater respect and have the possibility to escape the great horrors of the World today, thus moving the World up one step in terms of dignity and worth.
Note1: As people enter the academic discussion, they inherently commit to honesty!
Note2: They can call themselves doctors or whatever! They have been defeated! (That is, they're not "born" with credibility.)
Note3: (here) by Leonardo F. Olsnes-Lea on Tuesday, 26 June 2012 at 02:45 CEST as note to Facebook.
End note: The opposition is getting ripe for utter defeat and I hope you bother to make it clear by making the defeat more firm the next few months and years to come!
- the "Slippery Slope" defeats itself (by fake ethics) by protecting hugely crazy people who have absolutely no problems accepting the devastation brought by it on human dignity and human worth/decency and how torture inflicts terror and deep fears, even sublimely, on the rest of the population.
- secondly, and more directly, the Slippery Slope never accounts for formal qualification, while citing this Nazi program "so seriously", "as if their whole bodies would be immersed", such as obtaining 3-year therapy after the age of 18 before getting the approval for suicide!
- "The Slippery Slope", in addition, has no concept or credible prediction for how many people Slippery Slope will affect outside those already, virtually, queued in! When 36 000 people die from guns (or gun deaths) in USA every year, would the rest of USA therefore get killed by guns next year? NO! Why is this? Because troubles need to obtain in certain ways first! This has a direct analogy to legislated suicides in that this counters the very Slippery Slope argument and the way these disgusting people (complex, as with traits of psychopathy and mis-a/-ophiles) remain active in society, "defending humanity" still! There is no doubt where I want: (Assisted) Suicides need legal defence/legislation and practice urgently so that people can achieve greater respect and have the possibility to escape the great horrors of the World today, thus moving the World up one step in terms of dignity and worth.
Note1: As people enter the academic discussion, they inherently commit to honesty!
Note2: They can call themselves doctors or whatever! They have been defeated! (That is, they're not "born" with credibility.)
Note3: (here) by Leonardo F. Olsnes-Lea on Tuesday, 26 June 2012 at 02:45 CEST as note to Facebook.
End note: The opposition is getting ripe for utter defeat and I hope you bother to make it clear by making the defeat more firm the next few months and years to come!
Saturday, 16 June 2012
(Assisted) Suicide - The Final Argument Pro Suicide as a Matter of Applied Ethics
Examination! Time for "inquisition"! I've made this topic because I think there are some (really) disgusting or stupid arguments against (Assisted) Suicide.
First of all, those who seriously argue for the right to (Assisted) Suicide (A)S seems to have the greatest integrity of the subject they're speaking of. Necessarily, those who oppose it, are on the outside of the situation, but may very well have been considering (Assisted) Suicide in the past.
Now, one person, Simone, argues in favour:
1. People like to have the possibility to die, (A)S, if they are in great pain and are bound to die (terminally ill).
2. People like to have the possibility to die, (A)S, if they are losing their mind (fx. Alzheimer's).
3. People like to have the possibility to die, (A)S, if they are in great mental pain/distress to which there's no hope and there's no-one willing to significantly change the situation.
4. Combination of two or more of 1., 2. and 3.
5. People should have the possibility to (A)S so that people can't be kept as virtual slaves anymore or forced to compromise on themselves to that extent. 6. People should have the possibility to (A)S so that people aren't forced to compromise on themselves to any extent (by 1., 2., 3. and 4.), calling the situation for what it is, making the possibility to (A)S possibly less restrictive. 7. There's more dignity in dying reasonably healthy and able (by/implied by X. in post #4 on the PF forum).
8. If I have no constructive role in society, being an adult, and I have the urge to commit suicide. It should be my right to commit this suicide or else I might get involved with illegal guns and homicide(s). Being an adult involves knowing what's best for yourself as you are closest to yourself and clearly then, I'm ethically/lawfully entitled to choose my destiny of suicide in my own opinion. Therefore, also, I demand it!
9. We should allow people to die by 1. and 2., possibly also by 3., 5. and 6. because it's the decent approach to the matters (by Apathy Kills in post #18 on the PF forum). There's a certain power in using the word, "decent", here and I'd like you to contemplate this.
10. The fact that people are driven down to basic instincts, into corners of despair, forced to compromise on themselves is necessarily leading to unnecessary friction and unhealthy tendencies in society. (A)S should therefore be allowed! (I think this is slightly different than 4. and 5.)
11. Acknowledging point 5. of the opposition, I do still think the defacto performance of society in telling people to "get out of the way" in a possibly hidden and cruel manner (if nothing else then implicitly by use of threats and fear) is true whether this is unexpressed or not (because I can think of such thought as having existence, plausibly).
12. A sticking point to decide who has the most respect for the topic of this discussion, i.e. to allow eutanasia is as follows:Given the respect for mental health that equals the respect for life as such so
it follows that, granted the awful pains, unbearable as such, can give rise to vast personality change, undesired, and insanity. If it is now the case that respect for the person equals the respect for life (and death) then they who are pro-eutanasia have the final say of the matter at hand, whether to allow eutanasia or not. This can certainly be set up logically as valid deduction ("so do not try it!").
(It should be noted that assisted suicides if they become legal, always are qualified (by whatever requirements), assisted suicides. This is implicit, but now it's explicit!)
One person, Peter, argues against:
1. People should not have the possibility to die, (A)S, because of (my) (presumably) view of the sanctity of life.
2. People should not have the possibility to die, (A)S, because (unfounded) "it's the wrong signal to give".
3. In the case of older people, they may (mis-) perceive their burden on family and friends in an unproportionate way and thus wrongly requesting, wanting or actually committing suicide.
4. There simply is no unbearable/painful situation and therefore all suicides are wrong.
5. By allowing people suicide, one may give a (possibly subtle) signal that people should "get out of the way" and consequently devalue the human life. Therefore, suicide should not be legal. (This may likely be the real argument of 2. while 2. is just a "social" signal of ambiguity.)
6. By denying people (assisted) suicide, one (unfounded) prevents possibly a number of suicides. Therefore, suicide should not be legal. (By atightropewalker in post #47.)
It seems to me to be common to somehow discredit the person who wants to commit suicide by being in doubt of the person's intelligence, sanity or cognition of circumstances.
I'd like you to add arguments to either of these two people. I'd also like you to list possible hidden motives with either of these two persons.
Like this:
Hidden, Peter, "I like the fact that people die in severe pain and I also like the melancholy of thinking so."
Hidden, Peter, "I like the fact that people go through great pains before getting finally getting it done in all sorts of funny ways. Heck, it's a jungle out there and I'm an explorer!"
Hidden, Peter, "If we give people the possibility to (A)S, people can't be kept as virtual slaves anymore or forced to compromise on themselves to that extent." Consequently, I also like you to note the possibilities of Simone having hidden motives and the very nature of them.
I also like to point out the usual ordeal of suicides. You know, people sobbing and complaining about losing someone beloved, but where are the f**king stories of these (deprived) people who commit suicides? Am I supposed to think they killed themselves because of some illusion? Hah, no way! If I'm supposed to think about suicide, it's the freaking last thing, I think about! I think it's so bloody clear, but people just shut up out of politeness or something. Psychiatry should have rife possibilities on telling people what kind of conditions that drive people into suicide, but do they? F**king never!
Objectively, every possible argument in the discussion of (A)S will take effect and thus be effectuated or denied.
Generally to the debates, the rule of honesty and fairness: Remember that the debate should be fair / honest and that it is therefore expected that the debaters pass present lie detectors. Well, these lie-detectors 4 different methods simultaneously used, mimicry and eye-dialation, polygraph test, voice stress analyser and (f) MRI for lie pattern in the brain.
You may find this interesting: "Autopsy of a Suicidal Mind
Edwin S. Shneidman, Ph.D., 2004, Oxford University Press.
Autopsy of a Suicidal Mind is a uniquely intensive psychological analysis of a suicidal mind. In this poignant scientific study, the author assembles an extraordinary cast of eight renowned experts to analyze the suicidal materials, including a ten-page suicide note, given to him by a distraught mother looking for insights into her son's tragic death. Each of the eight experts offers a unique perspective and the sum of their conclusions constitutes an extraordinary psychological autopsy. This book is the first of its kind and a remarkable contribution to the study of suicide." I note that this is from 2004 (why not 1985?).
Important:
People may say that they don't subscribe to all or some of the points or that they certainly not subscribe to the hidden motives (of some people). Their very subscription may very well be so, but this doesn't undercut the fact that their position may support it, objectively! Undeniably then, every possible argument in the discussion of (A)S will take part and thus be effectuated or denied. It should on the other hand, incline them to take part in the debate of preventing this kind of vicious thinking or act in different ways to prevent suicide altogether. Clearly, they will fail to prevent the possibility of such attitudes and I think the massive problem of suicide and its origins are too great to make any solid impact on the matter by practical action. Surely then, this impels a certain kind of dissemination of information. Has Simone won?
By examining the reasons for suicide, it can become a right to commit suicide. Open discussions will decide the laws in the various legislative domains/states and nations. This right can be qualified by fulfilling a set of requirements. I also think if people have a real chance to commit suicide legally, they will embark on a different procedure in relation to family and friends. There's also a chance that family and friends will care more and be more alert to factors leading to suicidal tendencies and the whole debate may also take on better characteristics.
Following the pattern of abortion that must be said to be very successful if you look closely on the statistics (leading to more: well being of kids, quality time, time for attention and love and so on), excluding, of course, the Christian conservatives (for them, we go the Hell all the same), I think this can turn out well for legalised (assisted) suicides too, that it gets accepted among the greater parts of the population, that for some, suicide by medicines is a good solution to sickness and other. There's nothing in the way for the possibility that near, dear people can take part in one's departure from life. The very (A)S can represent dignity in many ways, not to say fill many empty spaces (to make society "complete").
I think legalising suicide has the capacity to slash the "doctors'" vile, perverse, gruesome "games" quite heavily to put it bluntly (despite their, the medical doctors, Hippocratic oath)!
The final death to the Con-side of legalising (assisted) suicide: The Hippocratic Oath poses in NO way any more charity toward anti-suicide than the charity of those who are in favour because both sides may equally say that they support the best humanity and the best dignity of it.
Thus, the mere uttering of a certain "devotion" to dignity is no point as such! Therefore, "I claim to follow the Hippocratic Oath" is just a blow in the air in this sense/relation!
4. People suicide, i.e., the suicide numbers, by
hearsay, more than one million deaths every year.
The conclusion here is that people are unquestionably! I don't want to hear the slightest (lying) denial of this! And that this suffering, much because of corruption with the police, lawyers and doctors, cause suicides on the scale mentioned, 1 million in 1999, more than in all wars on Earth combined! I say, LET'S TAKE THEM ON. WE HAVE IDENTIFIED THESE RODENTS NOW AND THAT WE ARE TO PLAY THE WHOLE BOOK OF TRICKS AND MISBEHAVE IN ORDER TO LAND GREATER DIGNITY OUT OF ETHICS AND COSTING THESE RETARDS IN THE PROCESS! Good? Understand?
Of course then, as you can read yourself, enter crime -> ECtHR -> Nigel Warburton -> Suicides! Entailment!
Even if these "angel" researchers (clinical/police/sociologists/psychologists/psychiatrists) tell you that they try to help people who are suffering from suicide-issues, i.e., that they consider to kill themselves, what guarantee do you get from them by that? Do they ever so much as (bl*ody) mention a time-scope? Do you see them somewhere in the legal system standing up for anything at all? Do they write sympathically in the newspapers about these issues so as to earn your trust? I can't see them lifting a g*d-d*mn finger for these people who are suffering. And that they do very little in terms of organisation or legal work, even by Amnesty International, domestically (they have duties by AI to care for all), even though, they have gained authority by achieving their degrees. What I figure is that they sit there and do the ordinary and bumble about with little differences to notice whatsoever. So the "entailment" chain of logics above describe these problems, that people are suffering from criminal circumstances so that painful conditions obtain in them (because police, lawyers, and doctors are corrupt, to start with some groups). This argument, along with my description of a possible (class-action) lawsuit are here to alleviate all this awfulness so that at least the theory and the formal deficiencies are described! And this is important beyond words to have this in place. Therefore, this whole argument you see unfolding here may provide for lots of people to either die with dignity or to (consciously) live with dignity. This is the feat of this text on my blog, that we've disclosed these freaked people and that we will fight in order to see increased levels of dignity worldwide!
PS: I also note that the President of the Norwegian Doctor's Association is against (A)S and that other doctors (tossing in the "authority" and "status") also are usually in favour, citing Hippocratic Oath. This is in no way anything objectional and one is entitled the view, but still... (and silent waters run deep).
PS2: If I, by this, get to inform people and also get to sway opinion into being in favour of (A)S, taking the correct (ethical) view on the issue according to myself, I'll be a very happy person!
Note1: If one allows one suicide, it doesn't necessarily mean that you allow one more suicide. It can be that one "palliative" assisted suicide is prevented or that one actual suicide is prevented. Either way, assisted suicides can't be said to necessarily have a bearing on the total number of suicides, actual or possible.
Note2 on sources of text:
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 11:58 pm; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2010 10:26 pm; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 11:14 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 11:14 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Sat Sep 25, 2010 11:24 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 5:28 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2015 ---- CET (UTC+1 hour): www.facebook.com/leonardoolsneslea
First of all, those who seriously argue for the right to (Assisted) Suicide (A)S seems to have the greatest integrity of the subject they're speaking of. Necessarily, those who oppose it, are on the outside of the situation, but may very well have been considering (Assisted) Suicide in the past.
Now, one person, Simone, argues in favour:
1. People like to have the possibility to die, (A)S, if they are in great pain and are bound to die (terminally ill).
2. People like to have the possibility to die, (A)S, if they are losing their mind (fx. Alzheimer's).
3. People like to have the possibility to die, (A)S, if they are in great mental pain/distress to which there's no hope and there's no-one willing to significantly change the situation.
4. Combination of two or more of 1., 2. and 3.
5. People should have the possibility to (A)S so that people can't be kept as virtual slaves anymore or forced to compromise on themselves to that extent. 6. People should have the possibility to (A)S so that people aren't forced to compromise on themselves to any extent (by 1., 2., 3. and 4.), calling the situation for what it is, making the possibility to (A)S possibly less restrictive. 7. There's more dignity in dying reasonably healthy and able (by/implied by X. in post #4 on the PF forum).
8. If I have no constructive role in society, being an adult, and I have the urge to commit suicide. It should be my right to commit this suicide or else I might get involved with illegal guns and homicide(s). Being an adult involves knowing what's best for yourself as you are closest to yourself and clearly then, I'm ethically/lawfully entitled to choose my destiny of suicide in my own opinion. Therefore, also, I demand it!
9. We should allow people to die by 1. and 2., possibly also by 3., 5. and 6. because it's the decent approach to the matters (by Apathy Kills in post #18 on the PF forum). There's a certain power in using the word, "decent", here and I'd like you to contemplate this.
10. The fact that people are driven down to basic instincts, into corners of despair, forced to compromise on themselves is necessarily leading to unnecessary friction and unhealthy tendencies in society. (A)S should therefore be allowed! (I think this is slightly different than 4. and 5.)
11. Acknowledging point 5. of the opposition, I do still think the defacto performance of society in telling people to "get out of the way" in a possibly hidden and cruel manner (if nothing else then implicitly by use of threats and fear) is true whether this is unexpressed or not (because I can think of such thought as having existence, plausibly).
12. A sticking point to decide who has the most respect for the topic of this discussion, i.e. to allow eutanasia is as follows:Given the respect for mental health that equals the respect for life as such so
it follows that, granted the awful pains, unbearable as such, can give rise to vast personality change, undesired, and insanity. If it is now the case that respect for the person equals the respect for life (and death) then they who are pro-eutanasia have the final say of the matter at hand, whether to allow eutanasia or not. This can certainly be set up logically as valid deduction ("so do not try it!").
(It should be noted that assisted suicides if they become legal, always are qualified (by whatever requirements), assisted suicides. This is implicit, but now it's explicit!)
One person, Peter, argues against:
1. People should not have the possibility to die, (A)S, because of (my) (presumably) view of the sanctity of life.
2. People should not have the possibility to die, (A)S, because (unfounded) "it's the wrong signal to give".
3. In the case of older people, they may (mis-) perceive their burden on family and friends in an unproportionate way and thus wrongly requesting, wanting or actually committing suicide.
4. There simply is no unbearable/painful situation and therefore all suicides are wrong.
5. By allowing people suicide, one may give a (possibly subtle) signal that people should "get out of the way" and consequently devalue the human life. Therefore, suicide should not be legal. (This may likely be the real argument of 2. while 2. is just a "social" signal of ambiguity.)
6. By denying people (assisted) suicide, one (unfounded) prevents possibly a number of suicides. Therefore, suicide should not be legal. (By atightropewalker in post #47.)
It seems to me to be common to somehow discredit the person who wants to commit suicide by being in doubt of the person's intelligence, sanity or cognition of circumstances.
I'd like you to add arguments to either of these two people. I'd also like you to list possible hidden motives with either of these two persons.
Like this:
Hidden, Peter, "I like the fact that people die in severe pain and I also like the melancholy of thinking so."
Hidden, Peter, "I like the fact that people go through great pains before getting finally getting it done in all sorts of funny ways. Heck, it's a jungle out there and I'm an explorer!"
Hidden, Peter, "If we give people the possibility to (A)S, people can't be kept as virtual slaves anymore or forced to compromise on themselves to that extent." Consequently, I also like you to note the possibilities of Simone having hidden motives and the very nature of them.
I also like to point out the usual ordeal of suicides. You know, people sobbing and complaining about losing someone beloved, but where are the f**king stories of these (deprived) people who commit suicides? Am I supposed to think they killed themselves because of some illusion? Hah, no way! If I'm supposed to think about suicide, it's the freaking last thing, I think about! I think it's so bloody clear, but people just shut up out of politeness or something. Psychiatry should have rife possibilities on telling people what kind of conditions that drive people into suicide, but do they? F**king never!
Objectively, every possible argument in the discussion of (A)S will take effect and thus be effectuated or denied.
Generally to the debates, the rule of honesty and fairness: Remember that the debate should be fair / honest and that it is therefore expected that the debaters pass present lie detectors. Well, these lie-detectors 4 different methods simultaneously used, mimicry and eye-dialation, polygraph test, voice stress analyser and (f) MRI for lie pattern in the brain.
You may find this interesting: "Autopsy of a Suicidal Mind
Edwin S. Shneidman, Ph.D., 2004, Oxford University Press.
Autopsy of a Suicidal Mind is a uniquely intensive psychological analysis of a suicidal mind. In this poignant scientific study, the author assembles an extraordinary cast of eight renowned experts to analyze the suicidal materials, including a ten-page suicide note, given to him by a distraught mother looking for insights into her son's tragic death. Each of the eight experts offers a unique perspective and the sum of their conclusions constitutes an extraordinary psychological autopsy. This book is the first of its kind and a remarkable contribution to the study of suicide." I note that this is from 2004 (why not 1985?).
Important:
People may say that they don't subscribe to all or some of the points or that they certainly not subscribe to the hidden motives (of some people). Their very subscription may very well be so, but this doesn't undercut the fact that their position may support it, objectively! Undeniably then, every possible argument in the discussion of (A)S will take part and thus be effectuated or denied. It should on the other hand, incline them to take part in the debate of preventing this kind of vicious thinking or act in different ways to prevent suicide altogether. Clearly, they will fail to prevent the possibility of such attitudes and I think the massive problem of suicide and its origins are too great to make any solid impact on the matter by practical action. Surely then, this impels a certain kind of dissemination of information. Has Simone won?
By examining the reasons for suicide, it can become a right to commit suicide. Open discussions will decide the laws in the various legislative domains/states and nations. This right can be qualified by fulfilling a set of requirements. I also think if people have a real chance to commit suicide legally, they will embark on a different procedure in relation to family and friends. There's also a chance that family and friends will care more and be more alert to factors leading to suicidal tendencies and the whole debate may also take on better characteristics.
Following the pattern of abortion that must be said to be very successful if you look closely on the statistics (leading to more: well being of kids, quality time, time for attention and love and so on), excluding, of course, the Christian conservatives (for them, we go the Hell all the same), I think this can turn out well for legalised (assisted) suicides too, that it gets accepted among the greater parts of the population, that for some, suicide by medicines is a good solution to sickness and other. There's nothing in the way for the possibility that near, dear people can take part in one's departure from life. The very (A)S can represent dignity in many ways, not to say fill many empty spaces (to make society "complete").
I think legalising suicide has the capacity to slash the "doctors'" vile, perverse, gruesome "games" quite heavily to put it bluntly (despite their, the medical doctors, Hippocratic oath)!
The final death to the Con-side of legalising (assisted) suicide: The Hippocratic Oath poses in NO way any more charity toward anti-suicide than the charity of those who are in favour because both sides may equally say that they support the best humanity and the best dignity of it.
Thus, the mere uttering of a certain "devotion" to dignity is no point as such! Therefore, "I claim to follow the Hippocratic Oath" is just a blow in the air in this sense/relation!
Then the logical formal set-up, first we have the
sentences (UoD, the entities, the whole disposition will have to wait for
now):
1. There is a lot of crime in the World to such
extent that even the (principal) ECtHR gets a huge backlog.
The references: Crime takes FBI and Eurostat. ECtHR takes BBC News.
The references: Crime takes FBI and Eurostat. ECtHR takes BBC News.
2. And given that torture is part of crime then
people may be in a World of hurt "here and there".
The reference: Torture takes Warburton's book. (But AI is also reporting a good deal, although they are very formal. So instead of saying torture they point to "abuse" and "domestic violence" and that children died under "unfortunate" curcumstances. They do avoid the word "torture" because they are part of some kind of political game or something. Annual report from them, although not formally in.)
3. When people are in a World of hurt "here and
there", they want to suicide.
The reference: Suicide takes the WHO numbers, both for current (Wikipedia, but link isn't here because...) and this million.
The reference: Suicide takes the WHO numbers, both for current (Wikipedia, but link isn't here because...) and this million.
The conclusion here is that people are unquestionably! I don't want to hear the slightest (lying) denial of this! And that this suffering, much because of corruption with the police, lawyers and doctors, cause suicides on the scale mentioned, 1 million in 1999, more than in all wars on Earth combined! I say, LET'S TAKE THEM ON. WE HAVE IDENTIFIED THESE RODENTS NOW AND THAT WE ARE TO PLAY THE WHOLE BOOK OF TRICKS AND MISBEHAVE IN ORDER TO LAND GREATER DIGNITY OUT OF ETHICS AND COSTING THESE RETARDS IN THE PROCESS! Good? Understand?
Of course then, as you can read yourself, enter crime -> ECtHR -> Nigel Warburton -> Suicides! Entailment!
Even if these "angel" researchers (clinical/police/sociologists/psychologists/psychiatrists) tell you that they try to help people who are suffering from suicide-issues, i.e., that they consider to kill themselves, what guarantee do you get from them by that? Do they ever so much as (bl*ody) mention a time-scope? Do you see them somewhere in the legal system standing up for anything at all? Do they write sympathically in the newspapers about these issues so as to earn your trust? I can't see them lifting a g*d-d*mn finger for these people who are suffering. And that they do very little in terms of organisation or legal work, even by Amnesty International, domestically (they have duties by AI to care for all), even though, they have gained authority by achieving their degrees. What I figure is that they sit there and do the ordinary and bumble about with little differences to notice whatsoever. So the "entailment" chain of logics above describe these problems, that people are suffering from criminal circumstances so that painful conditions obtain in them (because police, lawyers, and doctors are corrupt, to start with some groups). This argument, along with my description of a possible (class-action) lawsuit are here to alleviate all this awfulness so that at least the theory and the formal deficiencies are described! And this is important beyond words to have this in place. Therefore, this whole argument you see unfolding here may provide for lots of people to either die with dignity or to (consciously) live with dignity. This is the feat of this text on my blog, that we've disclosed these freaked people and that we will fight in order to see increased levels of dignity worldwide!
PS: I also note that the President of the Norwegian Doctor's Association is against (A)S and that other doctors (tossing in the "authority" and "status") also are usually in favour, citing Hippocratic Oath. This is in no way anything objectional and one is entitled the view, but still... (and silent waters run deep).
PS2: If I, by this, get to inform people and also get to sway opinion into being in favour of (A)S, taking the correct (ethical) view on the issue according to myself, I'll be a very happy person!
Note1: If one allows one suicide, it doesn't necessarily mean that you allow one more suicide. It can be that one "palliative" assisted suicide is prevented or that one actual suicide is prevented. Either way, assisted suicides can't be said to necessarily have a bearing on the total number of suicides, actual or possible.
Note2 on sources of text:
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 11:58 pm; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2010 10:26 pm; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 11:14 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 11:14 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Sat Sep 25, 2010 11:24 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 5:28 pm UTC + 1 hour; forum.philosophynow.org
Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2015 ---- CET (UTC+1 hour): www.facebook.com/leonardoolsneslea
Thursday, 1 December 2011
(Neo-)Kantian Ethics, The Ethics of Integrity
(Neo-)Kantian Ethics, The Ethics of Integrity
[by Terje Lea 12. July 2011, time 06:22 by Facebook data only.]
Neo-Kantian Ethics, The Ethics of Integrity
Human integrity or the identity of the human
This is original Work by Terje Lea and it has been running from 1998 to 2011, today.
Represented by T + Olsnes-Lea / By Unity Circle
History. I find it rewarding to still keep this project going since its inception in 1998 and to keep the respects to the matter alive, possibly by the mere undertaking of documenting my angle to ethics and working it to a complete argument, thereby having it freshly in memory!
This is really coming down to moral.
There is no such thing as objectivity in interhuman relations. You will only find subjectivity and inter-subjectivity.
Science in the meaning of proving the truth for the public for the Beginning to the End.
For the sake of clarity and for avoiding misunderstanding, this is the definition of Integrity: Loosely from I. Kant, it is that everyone must preserve both the ends of rationality in oneself as well as the ends of rationality in others. Usually, preserving rationality means preserving the potential for maximal happiness, I think. Both as the joy for oneself to live and for the opportunity to enjoy life in general, both people and nature, with the science and industry included. I like you to take nature seriously in the aspect of ecology to support the rationality in yourself and others as nature is the basis for being able to safely sustain humanity and its prosperity (without breaching exactly this nature's boundaries for being a healthy nature with its wildlife and free development in it. Note that I write "preserve", please. Because integrity is to maintain humanity in oneself as well as others, all you need to do is to stay on its course, by duty and job requirement. As long as you carry out your duties relating to your age and condition, you should preserve your integrity very well. Do not lose rationality out of sight!
Difference in nature of integrity as interhuman relations. Individuals that meet, form their understanding of integrity out of the presumption of the other individual`s intentions.
Intension, Attitude and Action (objective) are the objective determinants of Integrity. Be careful for what you do, please! As an alternative to the Good Will of I. Kant, you can think of labelling your propositions in your head with the appropriate value, ie. wrong, right, unknown and undecided. This makes you more safely founded in moving forwards in life with regards to ethical and moral decisions you make. Not that both Good Will and this Labelling go well together because I think they do!
Self-realisation is realise the most of your human nature to the highest degree, intellectually and possibly also physically, while maintaining good health, and in compliance with sound ethics, i.e., ethical objectivity. It's paramount that self-realisation follows integrity in order to be this whole ethical/moral person. Otherwise, it's my theory that corruption and decadence enter the system.
One should remember that your Life-World, all of your experience, physical life, and all of your thoughts, mental life, consists of making the utmost of yourself where the starting priorities are yourself, eminently first, and following proximity thereafter, typically, family, then friends, then contacts, then business connections, then the friendly strangers, then the neutral strangers and then certainly last, the hostile strangers, the crime-enterprise crazies and the rest (incl. enemies). The existential starting point, in my opinion, is from the age of 18 with the actual luggage from upbringing, whatever it is. This does not mean that you are relieved from your duties before this, but that deficient parents, adverse social and physical environment can to lesser or greater degree prevent you from, obviously, becoming the best of yourself. Adversity in this sense is permanent adversity and loss because you lose a combination of time and opportunities.
However, as we proceed, your duties to this are therefore to work reasonably hard with a sound mind and having good personal security with the objective in mind to advance yourself in recognition and profit, on the personal side and to be constructive and of service to society, non-corruptively, contributing to justice and morality, on the other. A fine consequence of this is the advances in science and technology and the very excellent aspects of culture including the arts, more or less progressive. Therefore I've made the following drawings that you should associate this with.
The Good Will means...
[The following is added 19.02.2006. It is from the rest of the notes that comes with the Kantian Ethics.]
Integrity: Feelings > Expression separate from Rationality > Evaluation supervised by Introspection in between them
After Introspection, the process is Rational Feelings that are held against Feelings of the Beast.
Nature of Human vs. Nature of Beast controlled by introspection. Validated by introspection into according situation.
Preconditions: Rational feelings meaning feelings founded in actual conditions and underpinned and supervised by the Self by introspection.
Free upraising: Meaning the non-existence of abusive force that harms this child's integrity.
Teaching: Meaning to convey a message to anyone with retained integrity, without the use of force.
Conclusion: A human being with retained integrity ready to act on its own behalf and with the interest of retaining others' integrity and in order to self-realise its Self to reach happiness. [End of this 19.02.2006 addition.]
Impact on integrity. An action of revenge? An action of immorality? I find it hard to believe that people commit an action of non-passion using their own bodily sexuality! If an action is global or is affecting only a sector like a group or a single person, insofar as this is possible, is an open question that may best be answered by psychology. I do, however, have the suspicion that integrity is always affected globally, all of your relations. This will become more clear with this writing. I have the sense that every action is "governed" by "the perfect ethical system" because I believe ethics matter more than just mere taste, whether it is known or not! So when action is committed, it is mediated or moderated by your own ethical system, very distinct from "the perfect ethical system" unless in perfect compliance, whether it complies with "the perfect ethical system" or not! Thus, an action of revenge comes across as better because a certain morality is attached to it as is opposed to a crime of passion. Revenge is also better in settling an issue with a group or a single person because it carries morality. Unreasonable revenge that's not proportional to what the revenge concerns, is a different issue! A crime of passion may thus affect you globally while an action of revenge, if anything, has the possibility of being contained to just this group or person and thereby only affecting a sector of your integrity. My sense is, however, that this revenge nevertheless must comply with this "perfect ethical system" and therefore doesn't affect your integrity at all. Thus a wrong action of unjustified revenge may affect your integrity globally just the same! We are therefore back where we've started! Wrong actions, whether this or that, probably affect your integrity globally one way or another! Now, behave!
Note on Universality: it should be unnecessary to mention that objective ethics must be universal if one is to lead a flawless ethical/moral life. I see no possibility for escaping this and you should not bother with it either.
This is the temporary drawings and words of a system: Good Will Hunting.
In Jacques Derrida's tradition, The Deconstructionism, the ultimate tradition, the line of thoughts will be:
(Ethics) - Moral - Integrity - Understanding - (Subjective Truth) - Science - Truth
Meanings of Good Will Hunting, the movie, according to this system:
1. element: Orphanage corresponds to No meaning (empty world).
2. element: Violent action gives violent reaction corresponds to a principle of causality. (This element is an issue of discussion.)
3. element: Loyalty corresponds to retained Integrity.
4. element: Science corresponds to Truth.
5. element: The girl and the relationship with her corresponds to his Self-realisation and Happiness.
(6. element:) The overall target meaning with the movie was to prove that Thought is not owned by anyone and therefore the Value of Good Will Hunting in character is undeniable and supreme. Hereby the socialclasses will always be protected from being discredited.
This is written 1998 to 2010, including 23.05.2010, 10.06.2010, 04.07.2010, 17.08.2010, 12.11.2010, 23.11.2010 and 12.07.2011.
Back to the White Room
[by Terje Lea 12. July 2011, time 06:22 by Facebook data only.]
Neo-Kantian Ethics, The Ethics of Integrity
Human integrity or the identity of the human
This is original Work by Terje Lea and it has been running from 1998 to 2011, today.
Represented by T + Olsnes-Lea / By Unity Circle
History. I find it rewarding to still keep this project going since its inception in 1998 and to keep the respects to the matter alive, possibly by the mere undertaking of documenting my angle to ethics and working it to a complete argument, thereby having it freshly in memory!
This is really coming down to moral.
There is no such thing as objectivity in interhuman relations. You will only find subjectivity and inter-subjectivity.
Science in the meaning of proving the truth for the public for the Beginning to the End.
For the sake of clarity and for avoiding misunderstanding, this is the definition of Integrity: Loosely from I. Kant, it is that everyone must preserve both the ends of rationality in oneself as well as the ends of rationality in others. Usually, preserving rationality means preserving the potential for maximal happiness, I think. Both as the joy for oneself to live and for the opportunity to enjoy life in general, both people and nature, with the science and industry included. I like you to take nature seriously in the aspect of ecology to support the rationality in yourself and others as nature is the basis for being able to safely sustain humanity and its prosperity (without breaching exactly this nature's boundaries for being a healthy nature with its wildlife and free development in it. Note that I write "preserve", please. Because integrity is to maintain humanity in oneself as well as others, all you need to do is to stay on its course, by duty and job requirement. As long as you carry out your duties relating to your age and condition, you should preserve your integrity very well. Do not lose rationality out of sight!
Difference in nature of integrity as interhuman relations. Individuals that meet, form their understanding of integrity out of the presumption of the other individual`s intentions.
Intension, Attitude and Action (objective) are the objective determinants of Integrity. Be careful for what you do, please! As an alternative to the Good Will of I. Kant, you can think of labelling your propositions in your head with the appropriate value, ie. wrong, right, unknown and undecided. This makes you more safely founded in moving forwards in life with regards to ethical and moral decisions you make. Not that both Good Will and this Labelling go well together because I think they do!
Self-realisation is realise the most of your human nature to the highest degree, intellectually and possibly also physically, while maintaining good health, and in compliance with sound ethics, i.e., ethical objectivity. It's paramount that self-realisation follows integrity in order to be this whole ethical/moral person. Otherwise, it's my theory that corruption and decadence enter the system.
One should remember that your Life-World, all of your experience, physical life, and all of your thoughts, mental life, consists of making the utmost of yourself where the starting priorities are yourself, eminently first, and following proximity thereafter, typically, family, then friends, then contacts, then business connections, then the friendly strangers, then the neutral strangers and then certainly last, the hostile strangers, the crime-enterprise crazies and the rest (incl. enemies). The existential starting point, in my opinion, is from the age of 18 with the actual luggage from upbringing, whatever it is. This does not mean that you are relieved from your duties before this, but that deficient parents, adverse social and physical environment can to lesser or greater degree prevent you from, obviously, becoming the best of yourself. Adversity in this sense is permanent adversity and loss because you lose a combination of time and opportunities.
However, as we proceed, your duties to this are therefore to work reasonably hard with a sound mind and having good personal security with the objective in mind to advance yourself in recognition and profit, on the personal side and to be constructive and of service to society, non-corruptively, contributing to justice and morality, on the other. A fine consequence of this is the advances in science and technology and the very excellent aspects of culture including the arts, more or less progressive. Therefore I've made the following drawings that you should associate this with.
The Good Will means...
[The following is added 19.02.2006. It is from the rest of the notes that comes with the Kantian Ethics.]
Integrity: Feelings > Expression separate from Rationality > Evaluation supervised by Introspection in between them
After Introspection, the process is Rational Feelings that are held against Feelings of the Beast.
Nature of Human vs. Nature of Beast controlled by introspection. Validated by introspection into according situation.
Preconditions: Rational feelings meaning feelings founded in actual conditions and underpinned and supervised by the Self by introspection.
Free upraising: Meaning the non-existence of abusive force that harms this child's integrity.
Teaching: Meaning to convey a message to anyone with retained integrity, without the use of force.
Conclusion: A human being with retained integrity ready to act on its own behalf and with the interest of retaining others' integrity and in order to self-realise its Self to reach happiness. [End of this 19.02.2006 addition.]
Impact on integrity. An action of revenge? An action of immorality? I find it hard to believe that people commit an action of non-passion using their own bodily sexuality! If an action is global or is affecting only a sector like a group or a single person, insofar as this is possible, is an open question that may best be answered by psychology. I do, however, have the suspicion that integrity is always affected globally, all of your relations. This will become more clear with this writing. I have the sense that every action is "governed" by "the perfect ethical system" because I believe ethics matter more than just mere taste, whether it is known or not! So when action is committed, it is mediated or moderated by your own ethical system, very distinct from "the perfect ethical system" unless in perfect compliance, whether it complies with "the perfect ethical system" or not! Thus, an action of revenge comes across as better because a certain morality is attached to it as is opposed to a crime of passion. Revenge is also better in settling an issue with a group or a single person because it carries morality. Unreasonable revenge that's not proportional to what the revenge concerns, is a different issue! A crime of passion may thus affect you globally while an action of revenge, if anything, has the possibility of being contained to just this group or person and thereby only affecting a sector of your integrity. My sense is, however, that this revenge nevertheless must comply with this "perfect ethical system" and therefore doesn't affect your integrity at all. Thus a wrong action of unjustified revenge may affect your integrity globally just the same! We are therefore back where we've started! Wrong actions, whether this or that, probably affect your integrity globally one way or another! Now, behave!
Note on Universality: it should be unnecessary to mention that objective ethics must be universal if one is to lead a flawless ethical/moral life. I see no possibility for escaping this and you should not bother with it either.
This is the temporary drawings and words of a system: Good Will Hunting.
In Jacques Derrida's tradition, The Deconstructionism, the ultimate tradition, the line of thoughts will be:
(Ethics) - Moral - Integrity - Understanding - (Subjective Truth) - Science - Truth
Meanings of Good Will Hunting, the movie, according to this system:
1. element: Orphanage corresponds to No meaning (empty world).
2. element: Violent action gives violent reaction corresponds to a principle of causality. (This element is an issue of discussion.)
3. element: Loyalty corresponds to retained Integrity.
4. element: Science corresponds to Truth.
5. element: The girl and the relationship with her corresponds to his Self-realisation and Happiness.
(6. element:) The overall target meaning with the movie was to prove that Thought is not owned by anyone and therefore the Value of Good Will Hunting in character is undeniable and supreme. Hereby the socialclasses will always be protected from being discredited.
This is written 1998 to 2010, including 23.05.2010, 10.06.2010, 04.07.2010, 17.08.2010, 12.11.2010, 23.11.2010 and 12.07.2011.
Back to the White Room
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

And further, we (of Mysticism) say insanity MORE and they will _not_ even be allowed the smallest excuse for it even, no matter how hard HIT they may be!
Q.E.D.